The Best Holiday-Themed Restaurants to Dine in NYC this December

New York City sparkles brighter than ever in December, twinkling lights line every avenue, storefronts transform into festive wonderlands, and the city’s food scene joins the celebration with over-the-top holiday décor, special menus, and plenty of cheer. Whether you’re planning a festive dinner with friends, a romantic night out, or simply want to soak up the magic of the season, these holiday-themed restaurants in NYC will make your December dining experience unforgettable.

1. Rolf’s German Restaurant – Gramercy

A New York City holiday legend, Rolf’s is practically synonymous with Christmas. Every inch of this cozy German restaurant is draped in ornaments, garlands, and glittering lights, so much so that you’ll feel like you’ve stepped into Santa’s living room. The traditional German fare (think schnitzel, sausages, and mulled wine) pairs perfectly with the old-world holiday spirit that fills the space and the best part? It's decorated this way all year round. 

Distance from Moderne: 2.2 miles

2. Serra Alpina by Birreria – Flatiron

Located at the top of Eataly Flatiron, Serra Alpina transforms into a magical alpine lodge every winter. Expect twinkling branches overhead, rustic wood décor, and seasonal Italian dishes featuring truffles, hearty pastas, and spiced cocktails. It’s the perfect place for a festive lunch after holiday shopping at the nearby markets surrounding the Flatiron district.

Distance from Moderne: 1.7 miles

3. Miracle on 9th Street – East Village

For holiday cocktails that double as photo ops, Miracle on 9th Street is a must. This pop-up bar appears every year in the East Village and completely trasnforms every inch of the space with tinsel, lights, and cheeky holiday cheer. Sip on drinks like “Snowball Old Fashioned” or “Christmapolitan” while surrounded by glowing ornaments and nonstop Christmas tunes.

Distance from Moderne: 3.3 miles

4. Oscar Wilde – NoMad

If there were a prize for most extravagantly decorated restaurant, Oscar Wilde would win hands down. Known for its maximalist Victorian design year-round, the space goes all out for the holidays with thousands of ornaments, oversized nutcrackers, and themed cocktails that look almost too pretty to drink. It’s holiday glam meets old-world charm, and an absolute must-see. If you have experienced this restaurant during the halloween season, then you can only imagine how it comes together during the holidays. 

Distance from Moderne: 1.5 miles

5. Tavern on the Green – Central Park

Few places capture NYC’s winter romance quite like Tavern on the Green. With views of Central Park dusted in snow, sparkling chandeliers, and a roaring fireplace, this iconic restaurant delivers a truly magical dining experience. It’s ideal for a special holiday dinner or even New Year’s Eve. Make sure to plan ahead for reservations because this place tends to book up quickly and far in advanced due to its growth in popularity.

Distance from Moderne: 0.7 miles

From sparkling chandeliers to steaming mugs of mulled wine, New York’s holiday-themed restaurants deliver more than just a meal, they serve pure seasonal magic. Whether you’re visiting the city or a local soaking in the December glow, make sure to add at least one of these festive dining experiences to your holiday bucket list and spend a wonderful time with friends, family or loved ones.

HAPPY HOLIDAYS FROM YOUR FAVORITE HOTEL BLOG IN NYC!